Isaac’s Book of the Month
Amazing Spider-Man: Extra! #2
Written by Dan Slott and Zeb Wells
Art by Chris Bachalo and Paolo Rivera
Marvel Comics, 2009
Nothing against the first half of this special by Slott and Bachalo, but the Wells and Rivera story is my book of the month: “Birthday Boy” featuring Spider-Man and Wolverine. No wonder it’s amazing!
It’s a straightforward tale of Wolverine wanting a drinking buddy for his birthday and therefore calling up Spider-Man.
Wolverine would never do that! He’d rather grab a beer with Cyclops or somebody, right? This makes no sense.
Aha, but let’s take a moment and give the writers the benefit of the doubt, and ask how COULD this be true? Let’s say Wolverine would actually choose Spider-Man to be his birthday buddy, and now let’s explain the rationale behind this choice and really examine the relationship these two characters would have in the real world.
The story is a character study between innocence and experience, hope and cynicism, and could be told with any of a number of characters based on these archetypes, especially since for the majority of the story there is no wall crawling or clawing around, but two guys having a conversation.
But the fact that these two are characters that have a strong history behind them means we go into their dialogue with certain expectations, and it’s honestly thought-provoking when our expectations are subverted and we get to analyze how the writer is actually right on the mark here.
Delving into a practical example from the story, Wolverine is really the funny one here, and we always expect that to be Spider-Man’s bailiwick. But it’s no surprise that when thrown out of the black-and-white world of “hero thrashing bad guy,” Spider-Man returns to the more nerdish leanings we’d associate with high-school Peter Parker, who doesn’t want to ruffle any feathers and wants to just be done with the whole awkward situation.
Another example is our surprise at Wolverine’s sentimentality, but this is further evidence of the brilliance of pairing Spider-Man and Wolverine. Lots of X-Men comics have Wolverine talking to Cyclops, but it’s rarely in a sentimental fashion. So to even tell this kind of story for Wolverine you have to find a character that doesn’t interact with him regularly; Spider-Man fits the bill nicely.
The art is wonderful, very dark and human, and when there actually is some action Spider-Man is a vision of the very spirit of the original Ditko art style, and that’s a great thing.
The lesson is, as ever, always read Spider-Man books.
Miles’ Book of the Month
X-Factor #39
Written by Peter David
Art by Valentine De Landro
Marvel Comics, 2009
It’s been a rough year for X-Factor. And I don’t mean for the characters in X-Factor, I mean for the title itself. Marvel gave the art chores over to Larry Stroman for some godforsaken reason. I’m sorry, Larry, you’re probably a very nice man, but you have the distinction of being the worst artist employed by a comic book company right now. Under his art, the book became unreadable and I stopped buying it. I couldn’t even bring myself to steal it.
However, now with Toronto’s own Valentine De Landro providing art I can happily return to buying the title, and just in time for one of the coolest fucking things I have ever seen in a comic.
X-Factor has always been about the X factor — the unknown or unexpected. David has continually frustrated my expectations in wonderful and interesting ways throughout the title’s history. So when Jaime Madrox and Teressa Cassady’s child is born, it was bound to be an event that was almost impossible to predict. I sure as hell didn’t see it coming. I’m not going to spoil it here because the recap page has a letter from David asking reviewers not to, but it’s one of those things that makes your mouth open wide, cry “Oh no!” and then say, “That’s fucking amazing.”
Poor X-Factor Investigations, they just can’t get a break.
But beyond the big, series-changing moment, there’s a lot of other things to love in this comic. The greatest strength of X-Factor is David’s layered character work and how he uses it to create a unique team dynamic. X-Factor is one of the only team books I read that feels like a team book.
So, X-Factor is back and it’s a book you should be reading. It’s smart, funny, engaging, and you don’t know what David is going to throw at you next. Gotta love that X factor.