The Spirit
Written and directed by Frank Miller
Lions Gate Entertainment, 2008
By: Miles Baker
In the interest of full disclosure and journalistic experimentation, I wrote the first part of the review before I had seen The Spirit. I have been following the production of this movie with a morbid curiosity that stemmed from an assumption that this movie would be a pile of horseshit. The text in roman is what I wrote before seeing The Spirit, and the text in italics is from after I saw it.

It screams, "Horseshit, horseshit, horseshit!"
Frank Miller’s take on The Spirit is a disgusting piece of trash that should never have existed. It’s full of terrible performances, paper-thin plot, and unbridled misogyny. It takes Will Eisner’s iconic character and turns it into Miller’s last movie, Sin City, which is something it shouldn’t be. The film fails on two fronts: first, as an adaptation of The Spirit, and secondly as a movie you want to watch.
This was dead on. In fact, it’s actually worse than I had imagined. About 20 minutes in, two men walked out of the theatre: they had the right idea. The woman next to me, she fell asleep: she also had the right idea. I tried to keep an open mind. In fact, during the first few minutes of the movie I began to think “Oh, man, I might have to eat humble pie, there are some cool shots here and this is totally The Spirit. But then the movie kept going and I kept getting angrier and angrier.
Everything that Miller adds to The Spirit is something that shouldn’t be there. As Miller was a friend to Eisner, you’d think that Miller would try to adhere to his friend’s creation as much as possible, but he doesn’t. And every choice he makes shows him to be an amateur filmmaker with a budget he doesn’t deserve.
Holy crap, I’m fucking precog or something. The best example of Miller’s directorial ineptitude is in his use of two different systems for delivering exposition —both of them lazy and trite. The Spirit is sometimes positioned looking directly at the camera, telling us what’s up, and sometimes he fills us in with voice-over. The reason for going back and forth is unknowable to any human except Frank Miller. Any shots that go in the Sin City style of heavy whites on blacks come out of nowhere and grate against the flow of the time. For some reason, The Spirit’s shoes are white in these shots. At the beginning there are so many of them I was thinking that the movie should be re-titled “The Shoes.” It wasn’t a very funny thing to think, but at this point the anger was really rising.
The biggest misstep is casting Samuel L. Jackson as The Octopus. The Octopus is a mysterious and menacing character in the comics, only ever seen by his gloves or a mask. In the movie, they not only give him a face but also a poor characterization. He’s a cartoony idiot, and his paint-by-numbers villainy is an insult to the audience’s intelligence.
Actually, I was wrong. Everyone is equally bad in this movie. Gabriel Macht as Denny Colt/The Spirit is one of the worst performances I’ve ever seen. If you thought Ben Affleck was bad as Daredevil, you have no concept of how bad bad can get. To be fair, most of the things he has to say would sound dumb coming from anyone, but he can’t make anything sound good.
They say The Octopus has eight of everything, well, he has at least eight characters. There is little continuity between his dress, his characterization, or his performance. Sam Jackson’s the kind of actor you have to keep in line, otherwise he’ll just do whatever he wants.
There’s a scene where Sam Jackson dresses up as a Nazi to make a speech about world domination and genetic control. There’s a scene where Sam Jackson dresses up in traditional Japanese garb and has a couple out-of-nowhere anime-styled shots. There’s a scene where Sam Jackson smashes a toilet over the Spirit’s head and says “Toilets are always funny.” Someone needs to stop Sam Jackson from making movies.

"I eat diamond chokers like you for breakfast."
However, what really boils me about this movie is Miller’s use of women. In Miller’s head women only exist as damsels in distress or sexed-up monsters. And this film is a parade of chauvinism from Eva Mendes’ Sand to Sarah Paulson’s Ellen Dolan. They all exist only for The Spirit and are defined by their insatiable lust for him. Even the city is painted as a woman — dirty and disgusting and begging to be cleaned up by the male Spirit.
The misogyny is what really takes the cake. The Spirit has about seven speeches about how the city is a dirty whore/mother/lover that he needs to save. Frank Miller is a sick fuck. He also feels the need to be homophobic about Robin (The Boy Wonder) in this movie for NO REASON WHATSOEVER in a cheap gag about his “tight ass.” Seriously, Frank, you’ve done this in Dark Knight Strikes Back, you’re doing it right now in All-Star Batman and Robin - leave it the fuck alone. Just because you think Robin is gay doesn’t mean that you need to put it in EVERYTHING YOU’VE DONE IN THE LAST SIX YEARS. Literally, with the exception of co-directing Sin City (which I don’t think counts) that joke represents 100% of your creative output this decade. What the fuck is your problem? This isn’t a movie about Batman. It’s supposed to be about The Spirit.
Miller has just pissed over his friend’s creation like a dog marking its territory. It’s terrible that film audiences will assume the source material is this dreadful and this devoid of colour and hope.
My last piece of advice: don’t see this movie. If you’re really curious, steal it. Download it off the internet, buy it from a bootlegger, use a five finger discount when it comes out on DVD: anything that doesn’t result in these men getting money for this horrible piece of garbage. No one should get money for doing something so terrible to humanity.