By Miles Baker, Isaac Mills, and James O’Connor
James’ Book
Superman #677
Written By James Robinson
Art By Renato Guedes and José Wilson Magalháes
DC Comics, 2008
Last month, I spent $50 I didn’t have, to buy the first Starman Omnibus, despite the fact that I already own the original trades. Hopefully that establishes my cred as a James Robinson fan. His run on Batman and Detective Comics a few years back was the first time I remember really enjoying those books. That said, I’m pretty mixed on his Superman.
On one hand, Robinson’s trademark hip, pseudo-poetic style is present. On the other, I’m just not sure it fits with Supes. I mean, I can’t ever remember Superman calling anyone “man,” which he does here. It just feels out of character, too casual for the typically hyper-polite Clark. And it’s indicative of how Robinson writes all his characters. Green Lantern didn’t sound like the Hal I know, either. They both sounded a bit too much like Jack Knight for my liking.
The worst part is that this is in marked contrast to Robinson’s Starman work, where every cameo generally sounded like the character you knew, only smarter than anyone else was writing them. If the Superman Jack talked to in the last Starman trade was the star of this book, I’d have loved it.
Which isn’t to say I hated it. It just didn’t feel like the Superman I know. However, I really liked the stuff with the science police, and I’m always in favor of bringing back older characters into a modern setting, something that’s a specialty of Robinson’s. So it should be fun to see where he’s going with Atlas.
The art is fairly standard superhero stuff. It actually reminded me a bit of Frank Quietly in parts, which almost gave the book an All Star Superman feel. It’s very subtle, but it’s there.
All in all, this is a fun, well-written book. I’m just not sure if it’s a well-written Superman book. But look at it this way: for a Krypto book, it’s genius.
Isaac’s Book
Secret Invasion: Runaways/Young Avengers #1
Written by Chris Yost
Art by Takeshi Miyazawa
Colours by Christina Strain
Marvel Comics, 2008
I’m not a big Young Avengers or Runaways fan; from what I’ve read, their books have been fun, but not earth shattering. That’s chiefly because they don’t feel like they’re really part of the Marvel Universe proper. Didn’t one issue of Runaways have the super-strong girl Molly sucker punch Wolverine (or maybe Punisher) through a wall? All that really does is tear down our established hero to give a cheap boost to these kids. I know it sounds like I really don’t like these characters, but that’s not true — I’m just focusing on the negative here.
As each group of kids counts a Skrull among its members, this “Secret Invasion” crossover should have some really good stories — remembering that the shape-shifting Skrull’s are the main antagonists for this Secret Invasion. There should be stories concerned with these characters’ divided loyalties, but all we’ve been given is a view of some kids who are surprised when an alien armada arrive. And what happens when a cool fight scene is about to start? The story skips over to the Young Avengers getting ready to do something, and then the scene returns to the Runaways after their fight is done. Great lengths are taken to not show us the fun stuff of the issue.
Which would be fine if we were given a good amount of character-based stuff, but that just doesn’t happen. Xavin, the Skrull from the Runaways, makes an off-hand remark about ruling the world — mostly a joke in poor taste, but also meant to create distrust between the readers (and Runaways) and Xavin so we don’t know her motivations. But trying to make me think Xavin is a traitor like that only makes it more obvious that she’s a good guy. (That “ruling the world” thing did make Xavin sound like Vegeta from Dragonball Z though, so that’s cool. I guess that makes Hulking over with the Young Avengers the Goku of the comic. Also cool.)
The art was the same kind you’d find in the Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane books — and there’s nothing wrong with them, they’re a lot of fun with what they do, but it’s not an art style that should be used in a book that wants to be a big-time adventure comic tie-in type of thing.
Miles’ Book
Power Pack: Day One #4 (of 4)
Written by Fred Van Lente
Art by Gurihiru
Marvel Comics, 2007
I don’t know a thing about Power Pack, so a book about Power Pack’s origin is exactly my speed. As is this manic issue where our four pre-teen heroes fight an army of aliens that look like sharks and stop an annihilation machine that their father built. Overall, the book is a pretty hilarious — if child-targeted — affair, so I dig it.
Gurihiru studio’s art fits the book perfectly, with their adaptable toonish style. They create nice and clean figures and backgrounds with a nice amount of detail, which is perfect for a book like this which is trying to bring in the kids. The book won’t bring in kids, which is another story entirely, but I didn’t feel like I was being played down to — which is exactly what you want in a story for kids (see the movies of Pixar to understand what I’m talking about).
My only problem with the writing is that the children will slip in and out of child-speak and start talking like adults. Of course, these are pretty smart kids, being the offspring of scientists and all. And at least they when they do a bit of child-speak it isn’t too heavy handed with tons of missing consonants and the like.
If you’re looking for a book where good is good and evil is a race of alien space sharks than Power Pack: Day One is for you.