The Ladies Only List
By Meghan O’Keefe
Confession time. When I received word that I would have to make a list of my Top Ten DCU characters, I panicked. See, as much as I love my comic books, I am unabashedly a Marvel Girl. Sure, I pick up Fables and various BKV or Alan Moore titles from Vertigo, but I don’t read DC comics — even though it was the Batman- and Superman-flavoured TV shows and movies that spurred my imagination while growing up.
But then, I realized something: characters like Catwoman and Lois Lane have always been intensely important to me, even if I don’t know what they’re up to in present day DCU. And I think that early inspiration may be just as worthy as a valuation of current plot developments. So here’s my all-girl Top 10 character list.
10. Chase Meridian
I know she’s not a comic book character; she’s a Batman movie love interest. That being said, she is by far and away my favorite of all the women to carry the mantle of “Batman’s Love Interest for the Sake of Pleasing a Wider Female Target Audience.” I really don’t care about Vicki Vale, Rachel Dawson, or the myriad of what’s-her-names that have made-out with Batman over the years. On paper, Chase is similar to the other love interests: intelligent, beautiful and non-threatening. That all changed when Nicole Kidman stepped into the role and turned her into a sexually confident, gothic babe with a kick-boxing hobby and Batman fetish (more than intrigued, she’s physically bent on conquering the caped crusader). So, I suppose I’m applauding an actress more than a DCU canon character, but I feel that if more of “Batman’s Love Interest for the Sake of Pleasing a Wider Female Target Audience” were written with the same perversity, Bruce Wayne would be far more likely to finally settle down with a gal who gets his freakish ways.
9. Huntress (Helena Bertinelli / Helena Wayne)
Personally, I prefer the version where she’s Batman and Catwoman’s daughter, but that’s merely because I’m a romantic with a sick obsession with doomed relationships. That crazy warped universe version aside, no matter what her back story is, Huntress is one tough broad that’s always to be admired.
8. Black Canary (Dinah Lance)
Okay, need I explain? She’s just too damned fun, sexy, cool, etc. Yeah, I really don’t have to explain.
7. Oracle
But wait! Batgirl’s already on this list! Yes, she is, but to me, the Barbara Gordon who lived before being crippled by Joker is very different from the heroine afterwards. I can’t stress how important it is to show girls that even if they have been hurt, physically or emotionally, it doesn’t mean that they can’t still fight the good fight, and Oracle exemplifies this.
6. Poison Ivy (Pamela Isley)
For a while, growing up, I favoured Poison Ivy over Catwoman. For some reason, at the age of nine, her devotion to botany seemed to make up for any of her criminal master plans. She never seemed as evil as, say, the Penguin or the Riddler. But regardless, the thing that I liked most about her was that her greatest weapon was her brain.
5. Harley Quinn (Harleen Quinzel)
I adore Harleen Quinzel. She’s one of those characters who can only exist in Batman, balancing bone-chilling psychosis with winsome wit and charm. I sincerely hope that Nolan puts some hint of Harlequin in The Dark Knight—especially because it would be so easy to explain her dependency on the Joker if she had worked under the Scarecrow’s reign at Arkham Asylum.4. Wonder Woman (Diana Prince)
Arguably the first superheroine of any impact, Wonder Woman is DC’s great gift to 20th century feminism. She possesses all of the charms that a woman is supposed to traditionally have, but she kicks ass next to the guys, too. She stands side by side with Superman and Batman as DC’s great triumvirate of heroes, and while Ms. Marvel and Spider-woman have had their places on the Avengers’ roster, neither of them have held their roles with endurance, nor are they characters unto themselves. There is no Wonder Man from which Wonder Woman’s name and powers come from, she is simply in a class by herself.
3. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon)
Batgirl — in particular the Adam West TV show Batgirl — is particularly important to me. I can think of no greater wish fulfillment for a nerdy girl than to see a mousy librarian transform into a glamorous, flame-haired babe who is capable of saving Batman all by herself. In fact, much of my own personal evolution from shy dork to globe-trotting, auburn-haired improv comedienne probably owes a lot to Barbara Gordon. It’s more of an emotional than intellectual affinity I feel for her, but I don’t think this makes it any less meaningful.
2. Lois Lane
Lois Lane is the Elizabeth Bennett of comic books. She’s an intelligent, ambitious woman who doesn’t value being a wilting flower in the face of adversity — oh, and she’s got the unwavering love of the most eligible man in town (even if she can’t see it). Her tenacity is what makes her both maddening and appealing. She’s the kind of heroine that epitomizes the feminist revolution of the 20th century, and since his first appearance in print, Superman has been wrapped around her finger.
1. Catwoman (Selina Kyle)
One of the biggest fears that lurks in the minds of modern women is that they will grow up to become the crazy cat-lady. Selena Kyle is an unmarried, mentally unstable woman surrounded by felines, but I don’t think any woman would fear becoming her. No matter how she is portrayed, whether it’s a cartooned vamp or a purring Eartha Kitt, Catwoman has always been the one woman to hold the indomitable Batman in her thrall. Her combination of power, sensuality and cunning doesn’t make her a role model the way Wonder Woman might be, but a fantasy that appeals to men and women alike. She’s dangerous, but also vulnerable and redeemable, and that is the elusive cocktail that makes her so darn lovable.